Fingersmith by Sarah Waters (2002) – A Review

Sarah Waters’ Fingersmith is a gothic thriller set in Victorian London that intricately weaves together themes of deception, betrayal, and identity. The novel follows the lives of two young women, Sue Trinder and Maud Lilly, whose lives become entangled in a plot of manipulation, crime, and dark secrets. With its richly drawn characters, complex plot twists, and vivid historical setting, Fingersmith is an immersive and suspenseful read that explores the psychological complexity of its characters and the moral consequences of their actions.

A Twisted Tale of Deception and Betrayal

At the heart of Fingersmith is the story of Sue Trinder, a pickpocket raised in a den of thieves, who is hired to assist in a con aimed at Maud Lilly, a young woman from a wealthy family. The plan is for Sue to help Maud fall in love with Gentleman, a conman, so that Maud will marry him and allow him to access her fortune. However, as the plot unfolds, things take unexpected turns, and the lines between victim and perpetrator blur.

Waters’ skillful use of misdirection and narrative twists keeps readers on edge as the plot unfolds. The novel is a masterclass in psychological suspense, with characters whose motivations and loyalties are constantly shifting. The themes of betrayal and trust are explored in depth as Sue and Maud’s relationship evolves, adding layers of complexity to the story.

Themes of Identity and Self-Discovery

Fingersmith delves into the theme of identity, particularly how it is shaped by social class, personal history, and external expectations. Both Sue and Maud are forced to confront their identities as the story unfolds, particularly as they grapple with the choices they make in relation to love, power, and betrayal.

The novel also examines the role of gender in shaping the characters’ lives. Both women are constrained by the societal norms of Victorian England, and much of the drama in the story revolves around their attempts to break free from these restrictions. The novel’s exploration of female sexuality, desire, and autonomy is both bold and thought-provoking.

The Victorian Gothic Atmosphere

The Victorian gothic setting of Fingersmith enhances the novel’s sense of suspense and danger. The dark, atmospheric settings—whether it’s the gloomy streets of London or the imposing manor where Maud is kept—contribute to the novel’s sense of foreboding. Waters uses this gothic backdrop not only to create tension but also to explore themes of confinement and escape, both literal and metaphorical.

The novel’s exploration of psychological manipulation and moral ambiguity is heightened by the oppressive atmosphere of Victorian society, where social class and gender roles dictate the characters’ behavior and choices.

Conclusion: A Gripping Gothic Thriller

In conclusion, Fingersmith is a gripping gothic thriller that combines elements of historical fiction, suspense, and psychological drama. Sarah Waters’ masterful storytelling and intricate plotting keep readers hooked from beginning to end, while the novel’s exploration of themes like deception, identity, and gender adds depth and complexity to the narrative. Fingersmith is a must-read for fans of historical fiction, mystery, and psychological thrillers.