Comparison and Contrast: The Characters of Stella and Blanche DuBois in Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire

Comparison and Contrast: The Characters of Stella and Blanche DuBois in Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire

In Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar Named Desire, the characters of Stella and Blanche DuBois are central to the play’s exploration of desire, illusion, and reality. Though they are sisters, Stella and Blanche are vastly different in their personalities, perspectives, and approaches to life. Their contrasting characteristics create a complex dynamic within the play, highlighting the themes of conflict, mental instability, and the clash between illusion and reality. This article will compare and contrast their personalities, relationships, and roles in the narrative to provide a deeper understanding of their significance within the play.

1. Background and Social Status

Stella DuBois Kowalski:

• Background: Stella is the younger sister of Blanche. She was born into a wealthy family but married Stanley Kowalski, a working-class man, and moved into a modest apartment in New Orleans. Unlike her sister, Stella has adapted to her new life and embraced the realities of working-class existence. She is often seen as the bridge between the old Southern aristocracy (represented by Blanche) and the raw, visceral energy of the modern world (embodied by Stanley).

• Social Status: Stella's social status has declined since marrying Stanley, but she seems to accept this with resignation and contentment. She doesn't try to hold on to the past, unlike Blanche, and has made peace with her more modest life.

Blanche DuBois:

• Background: Blanche is a former Southern aristocrat who comes from a wealthy family in Mississippi. She has experienced a tragic fall from grace, marked by the loss of her family estate, the death of her husband (whom she discovered was gay), and her own personal moral decline. Blanche’s past is full of trauma, including her own failed marriages and the guilt surrounding the death of her lover.

• Social Status: Blanche’s social status is a major source of inner conflict. She longs for the glory days of her aristocratic past but finds herself out of place in the working-class world. She clings to illusion and self-deception as a means of maintaining her dignity and avoiding the harsh reality of her current situation.

2. Personality and Values

Stella DuBois Kowalski:

• Pragmatic and Adaptable: Stella is more practical and grounded than Blanche. She has adjusted to her new life with Stanley and is able to maintain a sense of peace despite the tension in her marriage. She values loyalty and family above all, even though Stanley’s behavior often challenges her.

• Moral Compass: Stella’s moral compass is somewhat flexible. She defends Stanley’s actions, even when he mistreats her sister, largely due to her deep love and loyalty to him. She seems to prefer the stability that Stanley provides, despite his flaws, over the idealized past that Blanche represents.

Blanche DuBois:

• Fragile and Delusional: Blanche is characterized by her fragility and escapism. She is haunted by the trauma of her past and seeks refuge in illusion. She often lies to those around her, particularly about her age, relationships, and wealth, as a way of preserving her sense of self-worth and avoiding the pain of reality.

• Ideals of the Past: Blanche has a romanticized view of the past, specifically the Southern aristocracy,
  Order Now