District 9 – A Powerful Commentary on Dispossession, Borders, and Human Rights

Exploring Dispossession and the Crossing of Borders in District 9 (2009)

District 9 (2009), directed by Neill Blomkamp, is a thought-provoking science fiction film that uses the story of extraterrestrial refugees in South Africa as an allegory for real-world issues surrounding dispossession, migration, and the crossing of borders. Set in a dystopian future, the film follows Wikus van der Merwe, a bureaucrat tasked with overseeing the relocation of an alien species known as the "Prawns" from a slum-like area called District 9. As Wikus becomes personally involved with the aliens, the film delves into themes of discrimination, power dynamics, and identity, using the backdrop of immigration and dispossession to comment on contemporary issues faced by marginalized communities.

This analysis will explore how District 9 addresses the themes of dispossession and the crossing of borders, particularly through its portrayal of the Prawns' experience as displaced beings, and how the film critiques the societal and political structures that define who belongs and who is excluded.

1. Dispossession and the Alienation of the Prawns

The central theme of dispossession is embedded in the experience of the Prawns. When their spaceship malfunctions and they are stranded on Earth, the Prawns are essentially stripped of their autonomy, their home, and their future. They become dispossessed in every sense—they lose not only their place of origin but also their status as equal beings in a new world. Instead of receiving refuge, the Prawns are corralled into a makeshift refugee camp in District 9, which mirrors the treatment of displaced peoples in real-world contexts, particularly refugees and immigrants.

The district itself is a slum that reflects the marginalization of these aliens, and their treatment by humans is akin to how marginalized groups are often relegated to overcrowded, unsafe, and impoverished areas. This dispossession is not only physical but also symbolic, representing the loss of cultural identity and the erasure of the Prawns’ history, much like how colonized or displaced peoples can lose their cultural heritage and sense of belonging.

For viewers interested in films that critique the dispossession of marginalized groups or movies that explore the dehumanization of displaced people, District 9 provides a compelling and unsettling portrayal of what it means to be stripped of one’s identity and place in the world.

2. The Crossing of Borders: A Metaphor for Migration

District 9 presents the crossing of borders as a complex and problematic act, filled with tension and resistance. The Prawns’ arrival on Earth can be seen as a metaphor for migration—specifically, for the migrant experience in which individuals or groups cross borders in search of a better life, only to be met with hostility, suspicion, and bureaucratic barriers. The physical separation of the Prawns from the human population in District 9 represents the social and political separation that often accompanies the crossing of borders.

The portrayal of the Prawns' "illegal" settlement in District 9 resonates with contemporary discussions about immigration, particularly the marginalization and dehumanization of migrants who are often treated as "outsiders" or "invaders." The Prawns’ struggle to survive in an environment hostile to their existence highlights the difficulties faced by real-world immigrants and refugees who are forced to live in precarious conditions without the rights and privileges of full citizenship.

Wikus van der Merwe’s role in the film—initially a government official responsible for overseeing the Prawns' forced relocation—serves as an embodiment of the state’s position on migration. As Wikus becomes entangled with the Prawns, particularly after coming into contact with their alien technology, his transformation reflects the gradual loss of privilege and identity that occurs when one crosses borders or is forced to live among those who consider you "other."

For viewers interested in films that explore the theme of migration and the crossing of borders or movies that tackle the dehumanization of displaced peoples, District 9 offers a stark and emotional portrayal of the challenges and injustices faced by immigrants and refugees.

3. The Intersection of Race and Dispossession

In District 9, the alien Prawns are explicitly othered and discriminated against by the human population, drawing clear parallels to the racial and ethnic discrimination that occurs in the real world. The film, set in South Africa, invokes the cou
Order Now